Skip to main content

New Research by Mixon Examines Recent Proxy Voting Rule in U.S. House of Representatives

A new study by Turner College economics professor Frank Mixon and his colleague Benno Torgler of Queensland University of Technology (Australia) examines the use of proxy voting in the U.S. House of Representatives during 2021.  As the authors explain, on May 15, 2020, House Resolution 965, which authorized “remote voting by proxy in the U.S. House of Representatives and providing for remote committee proceedings during a public health emergency due to a novel coronavirus, and for other purposes,” passed a full vote in the U.S. House, 207 to 199.  In addition to proxy voting, HR 965 also authorized remote proceedings in committees, for Representatives to participate remotely during such proceedings and to be counted for purposes of establishing a quorum.  Mixon and Torgler point out that proxy voting has been heavily criticized by some media outlets and others as an excuse for engaging in non-legislative activities, or for reasons far beyond its intent, such as campaigning for re-election, engaging in political fundraising, attending to events and family matters beyond emergencies, enjoying holidays, doing interviews, or for simply personal or political convenience.  The study empirically examines, within the context of the academic literature on legislative shirking, the factors that influence the extent of proxy voting by members of the U.S. House of Representatives during 2021.

The results discussed in the study indicate that majority party Democratic Representatives tended to utilize proxy voting about 65 percent more than their Republican counterparts, likely as a link to the usual higher rates of absenteeism among legislators with greater influence over legislative outcomes.  The study, which appears in a recent special issue (on public choice topics) of Frontiers in Applied Mathematics and Statistics, also finds that longer-serving legislators tended to utilize proxy voting more often than their junior counterparts as they were able to use proxy voting with less of an expectation of punishment from voters given their greater name recognition an political clout.  Most importantly, Mixon and Torgler report that legislators who skipped votes during 2019 were also significantly more likely to utilize proxy voting in 2021.  More specifically, the study finds that a one percentage point increase in prior shirking (in 2019) by a legislator is associated with a 6.9 to 7.3 percent increase in the number of proxy votes cast on behalf of that legislator in 2021.  As Mixon and Torgler assert, this finding supports the idea that the proxy voting allowance produced by passage of HR 965 in 2020 was simply a new avenue for old-fashioned legislative shirking (i.e., vote skipping).  In this case, however, Representatives could provide evidence of recorded votes, which shields them to some degree from electoral (i.e., ballot box) retaliation by their voting constituents, who may otherwise be frustrated by the lack of legislative representation from their shirking legislators.      

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

ABDC Releases 2025 Journal Review, Now Ranks Journal Edited by Phil Bryant

The long-awaited journal review being conducted by the Australian Business Deans Council (ABDC) has been released and there are a number of news items that relate to faculty in the Turner College. One of these is the ABDC's decision to now include  Compensation and Benefits Review in its journal rankings. This is big news for the Turner College as its editor, Phil Bryant , is a professor of management in the Turner College. The ABDC is proposing that the journal enter its system for the first time as a C-rated journal. Acting Turner College Dean Tesa Leonce sits on the journal's editorial board, while Turner College management professor Mark James has guest-edited an issue of the journal. Published by SAGE,  Compensation & Benefits Review is the leading journal for senior executives and professionals who design, implement, evaluate and communicate compensation and benefits policies and programs. The journal supports compensation and benefits specialists and academic ex...

The New Financial Times Top 50 Business Journals Just Released

The newest list of Top 50 journals in business has been released by The Financial Times . This list is used by many of the top business schools around the globe to evaluate business faculty. Containing only 50 journals, this list is generally too restrictive to use as an assessment tool at most business schools. The typical business school employs longer lists constructed by the Chartered Association of Business Schools, the Australian Business Deans Council and Scimago. The new FT Top 50 list is provided below. Congrats to Turner College faculty who have published from this list in the past, such as Charles Boster (accounting), Deborah Kidder (management), Laurence Marsh (management), Frank Mixon (economics) and Ed O'Donnell (marketing). Academy of Management Annals Academy of Management Journal Academy of Management Review Accounting Review Accounting, Organizations and Society Administrative Science Quarterly American Economic Review American Sociological Review Contemporar...

Fall 2026 Enrollment Around the USG

As we await official enrollment numbers to be released, we recently asked Google AI to provide some of the enrollment trends and changes for fall 2026 at the University System of Georgia's institutions. That query indicated that Georgia State University 's enrollment increased by 1.24% from last fall, reaching an institution record enrollment of 54,320 students. At the University of Georgia , more than 51,600 student applications were processed for entry in fall 2026, a record for the institution. UGA projected an incoming class of 6,250 students. Georgia College & State University received more than 10,000 student applications for the first time in its history. At Fort Valley State University , 3,310 new students were welcomed this fall, representing an enrollment increase of 27% overall. Next, South Georgia State College  reported strong early-semester numbers with 2,086 students, an 8.25% year-over-year increase fueled by an 18.64% surge in new student enrollment.   Ge...